Last week, the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reinstated the administration’s COVID-19
vaccine mandate for federal workers, but the ruling is not effective
immediately. This week, the DOJ is pushing the federal court to expedite certain
processes to allow the government to reinstate the vaccination requirements more
quickly for all federal workers and contractors.
In September 2021,
President Biden signed an executive order that required all federal employees
and federal contractors to be vaccinated against COVID-19. This executive order
also directed OSHA and CMS to institute vaccine requirements for large private
employers and certain healthcare workers, respectively. Earlier this year, the
Supreme Court struck down OSHA’s vaccine requirements for large employers but
upheld the CMS vaccine mandate for certain healthcare workers.
The vaccine mandate
for federal workers, however, never made it to the Supreme Court. On January
21, Judge Jeffrey Brown of the Southern District of Texas issued a nationwide
injunction on the mandate for federal employees; Judge Brown said in his
opinion that, while the president “has broad authority to regulate executive
branch employment policies, the vaccine mandate is not an employment
regulation.” In issuing the injunction, Brown cited the Supreme Court’s opinion
in the OSHA case regarding the vaccine requirements for private employers
On April 8, the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit overruled Brown’s decision that had
paused the mandate. The court ruled 2-1 that the lower court did not have
proper jurisdiction to block the mandate in the first place. However, a “buffer
period” remains in place before the ruling can take effect, which prevents the
federal government from moving forward with its suspensions and firings of
employees who have failed to either get the vaccine or declined to request a
medical or religious exemption. Additionally, the plaintiffs in this specific
vaccine mandate challenge – Feds for Medical Freedom and a union of DHS
employees – have requested a rehearing from the full panel of Fifth Circuit,
delaying the effective date of the ruling even further. The DOJ requested that
the appeals court “stay “the nationwide injunction the lower court issued in January
or move up the date that its order takes effect.
While 98 percent of
the federal workforce is fully vaccinated, agencies are still eager to move
forward with enforcing the requirements on the tens of thousands of workers who
have failed to comply. Most federal agencies planned to bring employees back to
their offices in-person in April or May and had hoped to ensure all
non-exempted workers were vaccinated as they did so. The White House has
estimated it will spend up to an extra $5 million per week the injunction is in
place on testing unvaccinated employees for COVID-19. |